Hyundai Creta vs Creta EV: Which is cheaper in 5 years? Petrol or EV, see full account

Which is better to buy between Hyundai Creta and Creta EV? This question is revolving in the minds of many buyers these days, especially in cities where traffic, pollution and fuel prices are daily concerns. The Hyundai Creta is one of the most popular mid-size SUVs in India, while the Creta EV is the company’s first mass-market electric SUV built on the same platform.

Talking about the price, the base petrol variant of Hyundai Creta starts at around ₹ 10.73 lakh ex-showroom, while the top variant goes for around ₹ 20 lakh. On the other hand, the base model (42 kWh battery) of the Creta EV starts at ₹18.02 lakh ex-showroom, while the long range (51.4 kWh) variants go for ₹20-24.5 lakh. Let us know which of these two would be a more profitable deal to buy?

Performance and driving experience

The Creta petrol comes with a 1.5 liter naturally aspirated or turbo engine, which is smooth but may seem a little sluggish in city traffic. ARAI mileage is around 17-18 kmpl, but in real world it gets 10-13 kmpl in city and 15-18 kmpl on highway. In cities like Delhi-NCR, it would be fine if we assume an average of 12 kmpl with AC, traffic and load.

The electric motor in the Creta EV delivers instant torque (255 Nm), making 0-100 km/h acceleration faster than the petrol version. Driving is silent, smooth and fun. ARAI claimed range is 420-510 km (42/51.4 kWh battery). In real world tests, we get 8.5-9.5 km/kWh in the city and 7-8 km/kWh on the highway, which means 400-450 km range is easily achieved in mixed use. Fast charging (50 kW DC) takes 10-80% in just 58 minutes, while a home 11 kW AC charger takes 4-5 hours.

5 Year Running Cost Calculation (Approximately 15,000 KM/Year)

The price of petrol in Delhi-NCR is around ₹ 95-96 per liter in April 2026. Considering the average real world mileage as 12 kmpl, the figures will be as follows-

• Cost per KM: ₹95.5/12= ₹7.96/km
• Annual running cost (15,000 km): ₹1,19,400
• Total fuel cost for 5 years: Approx ₹5,97,000

For Creta EV, let us assume an average domestic electricity rate in Delhi-NCR of ₹ 6-8 per unit (depending on the slab). If we keep real world efficiency at 8.4 km/kWh (mixed use), then the figures will be something like this-

• Cost per KM: ₹7/8.4= ₹0.83/km
• Annual charging cost: ₹12,450
• Total expenditure for 5 years: Approximately ₹62,250

Saving in running costs

EV will save around ₹5.35 lakh on petrol Creta in 5 years. The savings increase further if you drive more (20,000 km/year). If you charge ₹ 12-15/unit at office parking or public charger, the benefit of EV reduces slightly, but still remains below ₹ 3-4/KM.

EV is also ahead in maintenance. In a petrol car, the cost of service, oil change, timing chain/belt, clutch etc. is incurred every 10,000 KM. From ₹ 80 thousand to 1.2 lakh in 5 years. There are less moving parts in EV, only the cost of brake pads, tires and suspension is incurred. Battery warranty is usually up to 8 years/1.6 lakh KM. Total maintenance can be reduced by 40-60% in EV. Besides, these factors are also very important-

• Residual Value: The petrol Creta may offer better resale value after 5 years, but the EV market is still developing and there are concerns about battery degradation.
• Practicality: Creta EV also has almost the same space and features, but range will be a concern. Petrol is better in rural or remote areas.
• Environment and Tax: EV is a vehicle with zero emissions and reduces pollution. EVs get exemption in road tax and registration.
• Driving Pleasure: EV is more fun than instant torque and silence. Engine noise and vibration are more in petrol.

Total 5 Year Ownership Cost

• Creta Petrol: Purchase (on-road) ₹15 lakh + Fuel ₹6 lakh + Maintenance ₹1 lakh + Insurance = ₹22.5-23.5 lakh.
• Creta EV: Purchase ₹22-24 lakh + Charging ₹0.65 lakh + Maintenance ₹0.4 lakh + Insurance = ₹24-26 lakh.

The EV’s huge savings in running and maintenance cover the initial price gap in 4-5 years. If you are going to keep it for more than 5 years or drive 40-50 KM+ daily, then EV is cheaper. Petrol will be better for low running (10,000 km/year) or frequent long trips, as it does not worry about range.